To Check Out Everything We Have On 'BREAKING DAWN', Click the Button Above.

Monday, January 11, 2010

'Breaking Dawn': One Film or Two?


There is a lot of talk as to whether Breaking Dawn is going to be made into 1 film or 2, and everyone seems to have their own opinion on it. Me personally, I would LOVE to see it made into 2 films!

Why? Well, for one, the book is very long & has a lot of detail to it. Some say they could do without all that detail, but I personally could not. I feel everything in that book played a very important part in the story. Plus, I would love to see the series extended by one more film! More to look forward to, and more time to adjust to what my life will become when it is all over (LOL).

Of course, I would want all the SAME actors to be signed on for two films if that is the way the studio goes. If there is anymore actor switching I might snap...for real. I hate when actors change in the middle of a series.

I could go on, but I am more interested in what you think. Do you want Breaking Dawn made into one film or two? Why do you feel that way?

Leave me a comment! I am dying to know! (I don't hate, everyone is entitled to their own opinion)


post signature

13 comments:

AmberRMW said...

I feel like there are several places the book drags and could be squeezed down. Granted, the 1 movie would prob be 3 hours.

I just think if we pull it over 2 movies, then the movies will drag. Plus, I guess I don't see a really great place to divide it.

My biggest concern about 2 movies versus 1... R & K are getting huge & their schedules are getting intense. I wonder how they could fit 2 movies with all their commitments.

I think if either Rob or KStew say they can only do one because of schedules, then the decision is made. Maybe they should ask them...

My Twilife said...

From @twilightus No way they can do it justice in 1 film!

My Twilife said...

From @jjbeachgirl77 @MyTwilife I would like to see 2 films, it just makes more sense to me.

KPattz said...

I would like to see 2 films but would be perfectly fine with 1 as long as it was long enough.

Lavixia said...

I'd absolutely prefer 2 movies! It'd be more detailed.There're so much important things in BD that can't be ommitted.How can u put 800 pages in less than 3 hours without deleting a lot of details and parts? Almost everything is important in that book

My Twilife said...

From @Donnac07 @MyTwilife i think Breaking Dawn should be 2 films, there is alot in the book that needs to be in the film, plus it means more of Rob :)

jarkin33 said...

I am kind of torn on this debate. I would love it to be in two movies and for all the details of the book to be included, but I also think that there was a lot in the book that dragged a bit and definitely wouldn't be exciting/riveting onscreen.

There is a logical split where they could definitely divide into two, but can we fans wait that long?? :)

patricia said...

2 movies, this is one of my favourite books, we have the wedding,honeymoon :) pregnancy, etc.. I love this book. I think we need to write to Mrs. Meyer. She need to listen her fans

My Twilife said...

From @berenkuil @MyTwilife definitely two movies.. NO doubt about it!!

My Twilife said...

From @BabettevHaaren @MyTwilife one film, without any doubt.. I don't like it when a story is divided in two

Carisa/Criss said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
MNTwilightMom said...

Ok..I chickened out and deleted my 1st comment, but this is the same one just added a few things.. Sorry I don't want to offend anybody or have others think I'm a joke for writing as I do, but I'm a shy person who's just a passionate person as well...
(I should have a blog about Twilight, but there is just too many out there! LOL)

I debated if I should leave a comment, but what the heck! Why not! This is MY OPINION, so I guess it's ok!

1st I'm going to apologize because this might get a little wordy, I enjoy writting especially when I'm passionate about certain topics and the Twilight Sags's...
I'M VERY PASSIONATE ABOUT!

I ALWAYS HAVE TO DEFEND MY PASSION ON A DAILY BASIS, so please forgive me if I get carried away...

I was introduced to the Saga's late. It's only been 1 year and 9 Mths. since I became engulfed into the Twilight World and I haven't left yet. And I LOVE IT! I read ALL 4 Saga books in 3 days.
I still read them!

I have found my 2nd family, and have met some great people on Twitter.

The movie "Twilight" I thought was Great/Wonderful until I read the book and realized that so much was missing from the movie, but I still love it! I still watch at least twice a week.

New Moon was slow at first (book), but I eventually got into it. The Movie was kicken! I thought Chris did a Great job and followed the book really well.

Eclipse I enjoyed reading. The Movie Waiting...and waiting! (As we all are)
Mr. David Slade..HINT..HINT…A Trailer would be Great!

Now Breaking Dawn, this was my FAVORITE BOOK!
This book made me cry, laugh, smile, and excite me. It was the most intense book that I've read in a few years. It just sucked me in and I couldn't put it down. I've never had a book do that to me ever!

OK, ALL the Saga's did it to me, but Breaking Dawn really had an effect me. I do agree that certain parts of the book did drag, but most of the book was very active and passionate in one way or another.
It made you feel the love that Bella and Edward shared for each other. The love and devotion that the Cullens have for each other.

I honestly believe that Breaking Dawn needs to be made into 2 films, so the Whole Story can be told. Yes I do agree that some parts could be forwarded (like Jake running all over the country) Tell some parts of it, but the book goes into details about Jake and his journeys.
I believe that if the Movie was put into just 1 film they would just destroy the book and it's meaning behind it. I believe even a 3 hour film couldn't make up for the book. I do believe that the book deserves a good 4 hours to even tell the story.

This book has 754 pages (I looked to be sure) I just don't how they can make it into 1 film, and still capture the warmth, passion, & Love that went on within this book.

I figure it like this...it didn't ruin the HP Movies being split into 2 films it made it better!

Why should the Saga's be ruined because of it being split into 2 films? It can only make it better. It would make it better...

But as I've said before...this is just my opinion...I would be very saddened if they ruined Breaking Dawn and only made it into 1 film production. I feel that they would be leaving so much out...

Thanks 4 listening and hope 2 see you on Twitter....
MNTwilightMom

Flipy Wadler said...

I think the movie would be great as one or two movie but I don't think they should leave any details out and if it is two movie no actors should change.

 
Blog designed by TwispiredBlogdesign using Lily's Take me to the old world kit.